Yes, Calif,Your Prison Conditions Are Still Unconstitutional

There are many that believe California's Prison Rehabilitation System and other systems around the world have more sinister purpose outside of incarceration. Discuss prison topics here in California, throughout the United States and Internationally.
Post Reply
User avatar
Christina Marie
Posts: 9305
Joined: August 11th, 2005, 4:58 pm
Country: United States
If in the United States: Pennsylvania
What city do you live in now?: From LB to PA
Location: CA

Yes, Calif,Your Prison Conditions Are Still Unconstitutional

Unread post by Christina Marie » May 12th, 2014, 9:37 pm

Yes, California, Your Prison Conditions Are Still Unconstitutional

By Nicole Flatow April 11, 2014 at 12:58 pm Updated: April 12, 2014 at 9:34 am

In 1994, a federal court found that California inmates with serious mental illness do not receive minimal, adequate care. In 2005, a federal court in a different case found that the state had failed to provide adequate basic mental care in its prisons. And in 2011, the U.S. Supreme Court found that the state’s prison health care was so deficient that it constituted cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth Amendment.

But California still hasn’t gotten the message. With this litigation still ongoing, a federal judge held Thursday that pepper spraying of mentally ill inmates is “horrific” and that solitary confinement of these inmates has got to stop without approval by a mental health clinician.

“[F]ailure to properly consider the mental state of class members requires the court to act,” wrote Judge Lawrence Karlton. “If defendants fail to meet their Eighth Amendment obligations, this court must enforce compliance.”

Despite having made these findings before, California once again deployed witnesses to testify that solitary confinement does not actually cause that much harm. And it explained that the pepper spray incidents actually comply with the state’s use of force policy, arguments that Karlton took as further proof the state’s prison policies remain drastically insufficient to fix the problem.

On video footage of the pepper spray incidents made public in November, Karlton wrote, “Most of the videos were horrific; each was illustrative of one or more of the objective components of the underlying constitutional violation found in the court’s 1995 order.”

On California’s insistence that it is just fine to subject mentally ill inmates to isolation, he said, “the foregoing findings and the overwhelming weight of evidence in the record is that placement of seriously mentally ill inmates in California’s segregated housing units can and does cause serious psychological harm, including decompensation, exacerbation of mental illness, inducement of psychosis, and increased risk of suicide.”

More than 28 percent of California’s inmates are deemed “seriously mentally ill,” a common phenomenon in an era in which prisons have supplanted asylums. But underlying California’s health care problem is not just the high proportion of mentally ill inmates; it is also its severe overcrowding. The U.S. Supreme Court ruling addressed the overcrowding issue, finding that “no other remedies” for improving medical and mental health conditions “have been found to be sufficient” other than reducing overcrowding. “Short term gains in the provision of care have been eroded by the long-term effects of severe and pervasive overcrowding,” Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote.

In light of this reasoning, it is likely still the overcrowding that is exacerbating California’s problem. In fact, Judge Karlton found that one reason mentally ill inmates are being placed in solitary confinement is because there are no other beds for them. California was ordered to reduce its population to 135 percent of capacity by last June. But it convinced courts to grant an extension, meaning it is still permitted to operate at more than 144 percent of capacity.

In the meantime, some facilities remain so overcrowded that inmates have died over unsanitary conditions that include leaving prisoners to lie in their own feces.

Despite this insistence by courts that California conditions are still cruel and unusual, Gov. Jerry Brown (D) declared last January that the “prison emergency is over” and that California is on the verge of “gold plat[ing]” its prisons. ... itutional/

Light Heavy Weight
Light Heavy Weight
Posts: 1063
Joined: March 9th, 2014, 10:38 am
Country: United States
If in the United States: Hawaii
What city do you live in now?: Honalulu

Re: Yes, Calif,Your Prison Conditions Are Still Unconstituti

Unread post by bumperjack » May 23rd, 2014, 4:17 pm

Californias prisons started to use its Gymnasims in the 80's there are 35 prisons in the state they cannot mix the mentally ill in with the General population,if they are deemed a threat to themselves or anyone else for that matter,Its up to the Govner and fderalejudges to start releasing inmates not building more prisons we have the biggest penal system in the free world one state well the largest state in the Country,Unconstitutional,inhumane,overcrowed,you name it and thats the wide variety of things wrong with are prisons in California,they are a mess,period we live in a police state,lets hope they come up with a solution soon?

Post Reply

Return to “The Prison Industrial Complex”